|
Perception of Dental
Fluorosis:
List of Abstracts
In 2002, the UK MEDICAL
RESEARCH COUNCIL recommended research to determine "the public perception
of aesthetically unacceptable dental fluorosis."
DENTAL FLUOROSIS is a disfigurement of
teeth which affects large sections of populations exposed to fluorides,
whether from air, water, supplements, toothpaste or from foods.
Internationally, dental professionals know that dental
fluorosis causes emotional and psychological damage and has financial
impacts on its victims and on society.
Despite the fact dental researchers
have noted that "aesthetically unacceptable dental fluorosis"
"can
cause great psychological distress to the affected individual"
(2.0% - 12.5% of children living in artificially
fluoridated areas), they still recommend water fluoridation in
conjunction with the use of fluoridated toothpaste, varnishes, etc.
The MRC is subscribing to the "classic public
health trade-off" in which the teeth and wellbeing of hundreds of
thousands of children in the UK (and millions elsewhere) are sacrificed
in order to protect Government policy on water fluoridation.
Here is a list of some of the studies on the public
and personal perception of dental fluorosis which have already been published.
What other results might the MRC expect to find? Could
studies be DESIGNED to change the public perception of dental fluorosis
in an attempt to make people believe that fluorosed teeth are OK?
See Abstract Number 9 which shows that first year dental
students reacted negatively to photographs of dental fluorosis. Abstract
Number 10 is a follow-up study conducted when the students were in their
fourth year and demonstrates that the initial negative reaction had changed
to a positive one!
see
also paper
Public
Perception of Dental Fluorosis: "The crucial issue"?
 |
|
Very
Mild
|
Mild
|
Moderate
|
Severe
|
Examples of dental
fluorisis
|
1. Spencer AJ, Slade GD, Davies M. Water
fluoridation in Australia. Community Dent Health. 1996 Sep;13
Suppl 2:27-37.
The one health effect receiving attention is dental fluorosis.
Two phenomena are altering the importance usually attached to dental
fluorosis. First, anecdotal evidence among practitioners and media
attention point to both awareness of and reaction to dental fluorosis
in the community. Hoskin and Spencer (in
preparation) found that South Australian children 10- to 17-years-old
were able to recognize very mild and mild fluorosis and register
changes in satisfaction with the colour and appearance of teeth.
Even mild changes were associated with psycho-behavioural impacts.
Hoskin and Spencer asked eight questions on psycho-behavioural impact,
such as embarrassment of teeth or self consciousness because of
the appearance of the teeth. . . .The most
dramatic finding was the strength of the association of TISF score
with psycho-behavioural impact was similar to that of crowding and
overbite, both considered key occlusal traits driving the demand
for orthodontic care. The community recognised dental
fluorosis its impact as an adverse health effect of exposure to
fluorides. Other researchers have also reported the ability of lay
people to react to dental fluorosis in comparable populations.
|
| 2. Shaw WC, The
influence of children's dentofacial appearance on their social attractiveness
as judged by peers and lay adults. Am J Orthod 1981 Apr;79(4):399-415.
The hypothesis that children with a normal
dental appearance would be judged to be better looking, more desirable
as friends, more intelligent, and less likely to behave aggressively
was upheld.
Also see: http://www.dentalcare.com/soap/cws/psych2.htm
and Your
teeth make a first impression
|
|
3. Rodd HD, Davidson LE. The aesthetic
management of severe dental fluorosis in the young patient. Dent
Update 1997 Dec;24(10):408-11.
Department of Child Dental Health, University of Sheffield.
The prevalence of dental fluorosis appears to be on the increase.
Although in its mild form the condition
is not considered to be of cosmetic significance, the more severe
forms can cause great psychological distress to the affected individual.
This article discusses the prevalence and mechanisms of dental fluorosis,
and the aesthetic management of severe fluorosis in the young patient.
|
|
4. Astrom AN, Mashoto K. Determinants
of self-rated oral health status among school children in
northern Tanzania. Int J Paediatr Dent 2002 Mar;12(2):90-100.
Centre for International Health, University of Bergen, Bergen,
Norway.anne.nordrehaug@cih.uib.no
OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to assess the perceived oral health status
and to explore its relationship with clinically assessed dental fluorosis
among school children in Arusha town, Tanzania. METHODS: A total of
478 students (mean age 15.7 years) completed questionnaires administered
in the schools during May to July 2000. Clinical photos of the upper
and lower incisors were taken under field conditions. A total of 461
slides were rated under laboratory conditions. The severity of dental
fluorosis in the permanent maxillary central incisors was assessed
using the Thylstrup & Fejerskov Index (TFI). RESULTS: The prevalence
of dental fluorosis at TFI score > or = 2 was 74%. A total of 67%
of boys and 70% of girls rated their teeth as yellow to brown, 58%
of boys and 68% of girls (P < 0.05) confirmed dissatisfaction with
their dental appearance. Kappa values of 0.40-0.44 were obtained between
dental fluorosis (TFI > or = 2) and self-reported discoloration.
The proportion of school children reporting dissatisfaction with oral
condition and dental appearance increased with increasing TFI scores.
Stepwise multiple logistic regression analysis explained 21% and 32%
of the variance in the dissatisfaction with oral condition and dental
appearance scores; TFI scores 11% and 15% of variation in points,
and social and psychological variables 11% and 17%. CONCLUSION:
Whereas dental fluorosis at different diagnostic cut-off points impacts
self-rated oral health negatively, social and personal factors are
as important in shaping the responses of school children to oral condition
and dental appearance. |
|
5. J.L. URE-CIRETT, E.A. MARTEZ-MIER, G. MAUPOME, and A.E. SOTO-ROJAS,
Impact of dental fluorosis on well-being of
children's by their parent's perception in a pediatric dental practice
in Mexico City.
Fluorides and Fluorosis, IADR/AADR/CADR 80th General Session (March
6-9, 2002), San Diego.
Universidad Intercontinental, Mexico, 2 Indiana University School
of
Dentistry, USA, 3 Center for Health Research, USA
Objective: To assess the relationship between dental fluorosis
(DF) and the esthetic perceptions of parents of the children who
present it. Methods:Dental fluorosis may have an impact on personal
well being (WB) because it affects appearance of teeth and face
from an esthetic point of view. A questionnaire to measure impact
of DF on WB was applied to parents of children ages 7 to 12 years
that attended a pediatric dental practice. This included questions
to assess self-representation of psychological WB caused by perceptions
of dental appearance of their children and one question that differentiated
among esthetic concerns derived from DF to conditions, such as,
crowding, caries and periodontal disease. Front teeth were evaluated
for DF using TSIF index. Parent's answers to questions regarding
their children's WB were correlated with DF. Results: 28 parents
answered the questionnaire, 32% and 82 % of the parents reported
at least occasionally experiencing distress or being worried, respectively,
because of the appearance of their children's teeth. 18% thought
that it hindered their children from smiling freely, 54% reported
crowding in their children's teeth and 39%reported them as unsatisfactory.
39% reported presence of stains in children's teeth, compatible
with DF. 71% of children had DF (TSIF >1); 64% had crowding of
teeth Unpleasant color of children's teeth was reported by 11%.
There was a significant correlation between
presence of DF in the children's teeth and parent's reported concerns
(p < 0.05). Conclusion: For this sample of parents who attend
this practice, perceptions of DF in their children's teeth appear
to have an impact on their WB.
|
|
6. A.E. SOTO-ROJAS, E.A. MART`EZ-MIER, G. MAUPOME, and J.L.
URE-CIRETT. Impact of dental fluorosis on
well-being in Mexico City children. Fluorides
and Fluorosis, IADR/AADR/CADR 80th General Session (March 6-9, 2002),
San Diego.
Universidad Intercontinental, Mexico, 2 Indiana University School
of
Dentistry, USA, 3 Center for Health Research, USA
Objective: To assess the relationship between dental fluorosis
(DF) and esthetic perceptions that may affect well-being (WB) in
children in Mexico City. Methods: Dental fluorosis (DF) may have
an impact on personal WB because it affects appearance of teeth
and face from an esthetic point of view. Using a questionnaire to
measure DF impact on WB, 41 children ages 7 to 12 years attending
a pediatric dental office were asked questions to (i) assess self-representation
of psychological WB caused by perceptions of dental appearance,
and (ii) differentiate among esthetic concerns derived from DF and
other conditions (crowding, caries, periodontal disease). DF of
anterior quadrant was evaluated using TSIF. Measures of WB were
correlated to DF presence. Results: 66% and 81% of children reported
experiencing at least occasionally distress or being worried, respectively,
because of the appearance of teeth. 61% of the children stated the
appearance hindered them from smiling freely, and 34% reported them
as unsatisfactory. 59% reported their teeth were not straight and
20% believed they were unhealthy. 34% reported stains on their teeth
compatible with DF; 66% had DF (TSIF >1); 63% had crowding of
teeth. Unpleasant teeth color was reported by 20% of children.
There was a significant correlation between DF and level of concern
caused by dental appearance (p < 0.05). Conclusions: Children
perceptions of DF appeared to have an impact on WB, as measured
by a culturally appropriate research tool.
|
|
7. F. Wondwossen, A.N. str, A. B sen, R. tekle-Haimanot, Zenebe
Melaku. PERCEPTION OF DENTAL FLUOROSIS AMONG
ADOLESCENTS IN URBAN AREAS OF ETHIOPIA. The 3rd International
Conference on fluoride and defluoridation of water. Chiang Mai,
Thailand, November 2000.
Faculty of Dentistry, University of Bergen, Norway, and Faculty
of Medicine, Addis Ababa University, Ethiopia
According to previous studies, dental fluorosis constitutes a public
health problem, functionally and aesthetically, in the East African
Rift Valley. The aim of the present study was to assess the perception
of dental fluorosis among adolescents residing in two urban areas
in Ethiopia: Addis Ababa, which has relatively low fluoride content
in the drinking water (0.2 - 0.7 mg F/L) and Nazreth, with a fluoride
concentration ranging form 1.2 to 8.9 mg/L. Students, aged 12 -
15 years, enrolled in two secondary schools in Addis Ababa (n=161)
and two similar schools in Nazreth (n=178) responded to evaluative
statements concerning the appearance of anterior maxillary teeth.
Color photographs depicting dental fluorosis of different severity
(Score 2, 3, 5 and 7 according to the Thylstrup/Fejerskov (TF) scoring
system) were used as reference during structured interviews. Differences
in the distribution of subjects according to place of residence,
TF scores and perceived appearance of teeth were assessed using
Chi-square tests. A majority of the students from Addis Ababa (89-96%)
and Nazreth (64-100%) were dissatisfied
with the appearance of even mildly fluorotic teeth (TF
scores 2 and above). More than 70% of the students from both areas
confirmed a need for dental advice concerning fluorotic teeth with
TF> 2. Whereas only 2% of the students
in Nazreth indicated that they would feel embarrassed with mildly
fluorotic teeth (TF score 2), 23% of students in Addis Ababa admitted
embarrassment with the same TF score. TF scores of 5
and 7 were found unacceptable both in Addis (38% and 56%) and in
Nazreth)40% and 86%). Students in Addis, more frequently than their
counterparts in Nazreth, indicated that TF score 5 ( 53% versus
26%)and TF score 7 ( 59% versus 33%) was caused by neglect of the
children's teeth. Students from both areas felt that teeth with
TF scores > 2 would represent a disadvantage when going into
adulthood. The present findings confirm that fluorotic enamel defects
constitute a social problem among secondary school children resident
in low-fluoride as well as in high-fluoride areas in Ethiopia.
Also see: http://www.npwa.freeserve.co.uk/Ethiopia.html
|
|
8. Chikte UM, Louw AJ, Stander I. Perceptions
of fluorosis in northern Cape communities. SADJ 2001 Nov;56(11):528-32
Department of Community Dentistry, University of Stellenbosch,
Private Bag XI, Tygerberg, 7505. umec@sun.ac.za
The objective of the study was to determine the perception of fluorosis
in communities living in the Northern Cape Province of South Africa
where there is a considerable range in fluoride levels of drinking
water. The fluoride levels of the drinking water were categorised
as suboptimal (0.40-0.60 ppmF), optimal (0.99-1.10 ppmF) or supra-optimal
(1.70-2.70 ppmF). The teeth of 694 children aged 6, 12 and 15 years
were examined. Dental fluorosis occurred among children of all ages
in all areas studied. As anticipated there appears to be a direct
relationship between fluoride levels in the drinking water and levels
of dental fluorosis, and the severity of the condition increased with
an increase in levels of fluoride in the water supplies. Children
in low fluoride areas showed some form of mild fluorosis (37% very
mild and 17% mild). However, 19% of this group experienced moderate
or severe forms of fluorosis. In areas with optimal levels of fluoride
30% of children showed a questionable form of fluorosis and 21% mild
fluorosis. Moderate or severe forms of fluorosis were recorded in
31% of children in the optimal fluoride area. The Community Fluorosis
Index (CFI) scores for the sub-optimal and optimal areas were of medium
public health significance and for the supra-optimal area of very
high public health significance. Of concern is the high percentage
of children (45%) in the supra-optimal area with severe forms of fluorosis.
The awareness and concern for stains on teeth
were mostly expressed by children with moderate or severe fluorosis.
This study suggests that the proposed fluoride concentration (not
more than 0.7 ppmF) prescribed in the Regulations on Fluoridating
the Water Supplies for South Africa would minimise the risk of dental
fluorosis. |
|
* The following two studies show how dental
students become "desensitized" to dental fluorosis. In
Study No. 9, first-year students don't like what they see. By their
fourth year in dental school, (Study No. 10), their perceptions
have been changed!
9. McKnight CB, Levy SM, Cooper SE, Jakobsen JR, Warren JJ.
A pilot study of dental students' esthetic
perceptions of computer-generated mild dental fluorosis compared
to other conditions. J Public Health Dent 1999 Winter;59(1):18-23.
College of Dentistry, University of Iowa, USA.
OBJECTIVES: Few studies have considered people's opinions about the
esthetics of dental fluorosis. Assessments of fluorosis esthetics
can be confounded by differences in a number of clinical factors,
including tooth shape, color, contour, and gingival status. This pilot
study compared esthetic perceptions of mild fluorosis and other conditions
using computer-generated images made from a base set of normal appearing
teeth. METHODS: Entering dental students (n = 61) completed questionnaires
about four sets of paired photographs. Three sets consisted of fluorotic
teeth (very mild to mild) versus other conditions (diastema, isolated
enamel opacity, "normal"/control) and the other pair compared
two presentations of mild fluorosis (generalized versus limited to
incisal one-third). Six questions, both qualitative and quantitative,
were asked about each pair of photographs. RESULTS:
Mild fluorosis was assessed less favorably than normal/control, midline
diastema was less favorable than mild fluorosis, and mild fluorosis
was less favorable than isolated opacity. CONCLUSIONS:
This approach allows fluorosis to be better compared with other oral
conditions because the images are standardized. Additional research
with this method is warranted, including more variations in conditions,
more comparisons, and other study populations. |
|
10. Levy SM, Warren JJ, Jakobsen JR. Follow-up
study of dental students' esthetic perceptions of mild dental fluorosis.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2002 Feb;30(1):24-8.
Department of Preventive and Community Dentistry, University of
Iowa College of Dentistry, Iowa City, IA 52242, USA. steven-levy@uiowa.edu
OBJECTIVES: Several studies have assessed people's esthetic perceptions
of dental fluorosis, suggesting that concerns may be greater than
believed previously. Few studies have assessed dental students'
perceptions and none has done so over time. The purpose of this
paper is to report on changes in dental students' esthetic perceptions
of dental fluorosis and other conditions. METHODS: Fourth-year dental
students (n=45) completed questionnaires about computer-generated
photographs of fluorosis and other conditions, using the same protocol
as when they were entering dental students. Results were compared
for each of the eight images at the individual level using paired
statistical tests. RESULTS: Although many
patterns were generally consistent, there were a substantial number
of differences in results over time, concerning both the mild fluorosis
and non-fluorosis images. In general, students tended to score both
fluorosis and non-fluorosis images more favorably as fourth-year
students. When rating images from very pleased (1) to very embarrassed
(10), fourth-year students rated the images significantly more favorably
than they had done as first-year students for normal/control, incisal
third only dental fluorosis, and a more generalized, mild fluorosis.
Similarly, with a visual analog scale from satisfactory (0) to unsatisfactory
(69), fourth-year students reported significantly lower (more favorable)
scores than they had done as first-year students for the normal/control,
diastema/no fluorosis, more involved mild fluorosis, and incisal
third only mild fluorosis. There were no obvious changes
in the relative levels of favorable evaluation of fluorosis vs.
the other conditions. CONCLUSIONS: Fourth-year
dental students generally had more favorable esthetic perceptions
of mild dental fluorosis and other conditions than they had reported
as entering students.
|
|
11. Milsom KM, Tickle M, Jenner A, Peers A.
comparison of normative and subjective assessment of the child prevalence
of developmental defects of enamel amongst 12-year-olds living in
the North West Region, UK. Public Health 2000 Sep;114(5):340-4.
Chester and Halton Community NHS Trust, Department of Community
Dentistry, Countess of Chester Hospital, Chester, UK. Community.Dental@cahc-tr.nwest.nhs.uk
Analysis of data from a 1996-97 cross sectional epidemiological study
of the dental health of a sample of 12-y-old children living in Crewe,
in north west England was used to compare normative and subjective
assessment of developmental defects of enamel. Five hundred and twenty
two 12-y-old children from secondary schools in Crewe were examined.
One hundred and eighty two children (34.8%), had home post codes within
the optimally fluoridated part of Crewe. Using the Developmental Defects
of Enamel Index, 178 children (34%) in Crewe were normatively identified
as having enamel defects present on their upper incisors. Thirty five
children (6.7%), were unhappy with the appearance of their upper incisors
because of marks that would not brush off. Neither the normative nor
the subjective assessment of enamel defects demonstrated any difference
in prevalence between the fluoridated and non-fluoridated areas. In
Crewe, one in 20 children normatively diagnosed as being free from
enamel defects were unhappy with the appearance of their upper incisors
because of marks that would not brush off. There
are differences in perception between dental professionals and 12-y-old
children over the presence and relevance of developmental defects
of enamel. Further research is required if we are to understand the
difference in professional and lay perceptions of developmental defects
affecting upper incisor teeth. |
|
12. Moss SJ. The case for retaining the
current supplementation schedule. J Public Health Dent 1999
Fall;59(4):259-62
Health Education Enterprises, New York, NY 10017, USA. healthee@ix.netcom.com
Following ingestion of dietary fluoride, microquantities of fluoride
return to the mouth in saliva, but in quantities large enough to
facilitate the maintenance and reparative functions of enamel. Dietary
fluoride supplements alone are unlikely to be the cause of the reported
increase in fluorosis. Compliance continues to be extremely poor
and few children use supplements for more than a year and a half.
The amount of background fluoride resulting from dietary fluoride
supplements appears to be very small. Considering the almost ubiquitous
presence of fluoride dentifrice and the strong possibility of additional
unintentional fluoride ingestion from many sources, the present
fluorosis data is too amorphous to use as a basis for making reasonable
risk/benefit evaluations. Very mild and mild fluorosis is not a
serious problem for either the clinician or the patient. By altering
the present recommended dosage we may deprive children from receiving
a proven effective dose. One cannot make
a risk/benefit decision concerning an esthetic problem without involving
the patient's perception as well as the caries score. The apparent
severity of the milder forms of fluorosis lessens with age and a
community fluorosis index should be used only on populations who
are older than 15 years.
|
|
13. Mwaniki DL, Courtney JM, Gaylor JD. Endemic
fluorosis: an analysis of needs and possibilities based on case
studies in Kenya. Soc Sci Med 1994 Sep;39(6):807-13.
Kenya Medical Research Institute, Medical Research Centre, Nairobi.
The decline in prevalence of dental caries in the western world
is largely ascribed to the protective role of fluoride in water.
However, in several Third World regions, its presence in excessive
amounts has been detrimental to the health of resident communities
due to the resulting endemic dental and skeletal fluorosis. As a
prelude to introduction of preventive intervention among the affected
communities, there is need to assess knowledge and perception, and
affordable and effective possibilities. The results of such an assessment
which was based on response of mothers from two affected communities
showed that objectionable dental fluorosis was not viewed as a common
health problem in the context of other more common diseases. A reawakening
of interest and concern was evident when issues pertaining to oral
health were addressed. Dental fluorosis
was viewed as an important problem because of its unfavourable effects
on an individual's personality by between 60.4 and 84.3% of the
respondents. While 60% and over of the respondents attributed
the problem to water, knowledge on perceived methods of prevention
of fluorosis were significantly lower. Only 12% of respondents from
a relatively higher income group were instituting relevant preventive
strategies. Although defluoridation of water had been instituted
in one area, problems relating to wrong choice of water for defluoridation
to inadequate distribution of the defluoridated water were evident.
Education of the communities on methods of reducing fluoride ingestion
and the significance of the defluoridated water, rationalizing the
distribution of defluoridated water, facilitating collection of
rain water, protection of available low fluoride surface water from
contamination with agro-chemicals and household defluoridation were
recommended.
|
14. Rozier RG. Epidemiologic indices
for measuring the clinical manifestations of dental fluorosis:
overview and critique. Adv Dent Res 1994 Jun;8(1):39-55.
Department of Health Policy and Administration, University of
North Carolina, Chapel Hill 27599.
Several indices have been used to describe the clinical appearance
of dental fluorosis. The purpose of this paper is to describe and
compare the three principal ones in use today: those developed by
Dean (1934, 1942), Thylstrup and Fejerskov (1978), and Horowitz
et al. (1984). A recent index (Fluorosis Risk Index) developed by
Pendrys (1990) is also included in this review. The continued use
of Dean's classification system and derived index (CFI) for more
than a half century is testimony to its simplicity and utility.
The index has been criticized because the unit of analysis is the
person, because criteria are unclear for some categories, or that
they lack sensitivity, particularly for severe fluorosis, and because
of the way in which data are summarized and reported. The Thylstrup
and Fejerskov Index is appealing to clinicians and epidemiologists
alike in that it corresponds closely to histological changes that
occur in dental fluorosis and to enamel fluoride concentrations,
thereby having biological validity. The TSIF described by Horowitz
et al. makes a useful contribution because it provides clearer diagnostic
criteria and provides for an analysis based on esthetic concerns.
The Fluorosis Risk Index appears to be particularly useful for analytical
epidemiologic studies, because it is designed to permit a more accurate
identification of associations between age-specific exposures to
fluoride and the development of dental fluorosis. All three indices
in common use today provide useful indices for the study of dental
fluorosis. The utility of the Fluorosis Risk Index will be determined
as it receives wider use. The selection of one of these indices
for use in an epidemiologic study depends in large measure on the
purpose of the study. Research needs to
continue on the validity of these indices, particularly for mild
fluorosis, and on the public's perception of the cosmetic appearance
of teeth with different severity levels of fluorosis.
|
|
15. van Palenstein Helderman WH, Mkasabuni E. Impact
of dental fluorosis on the perception of well-being in an endemic
fluorosis area in Tanzania. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol
1993 Aug;21(4):243-4.
Department of Community and Preventive Dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry,
University of Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. http://www.cih.uib.no/journals/EJHD/ejhdv16-n2/ejhd-v16no2-page225.PDF
|
|
16. Hawley GM, Ellwood RP, Davies RM. Dental
caries, fluorosis and the cosmetic implications of different TF
scores in 14-year-old adolescents. Community Dent Health
1996 Dec;13(4):189-92,Comment in: Community Dent Health. 2000 Dec;17(4):261-2.
Dental Health Unit, University of Manchester, UK.
The aims of this study were to determine the opinions of a group of
adolescents about the cosmetic acceptability of a range of fluorosis,
investigate the prevalence and severity of fluorosis in the sample
and consider the extent to which fluorosis levels were related to
their dental caries experience. A random sample of 534 14-year-old
pupils from the non-fluoridated industrial city of Manchester were
examined for caries and fluorosis. Each subject then examined six
photographs of upper anterior teeth showing a range of TF scores 0-4
and were asked to rate the appearance of each as either very poor,
poor, acceptable, good or very good and to indicate whether they would
request treatment if their teeth were so affected.Four hundred and
seventy-six subjects (89 per cent) had TF scores of 0. Of the 58 subjects
(11 per cent) with fluorosis, 27 (5 per cent) scored TF = 1; 22 (4
per cent) TF = 2; 7 (1 per cent) TF = 3 and one subject scored TF
= 4. The subjects who had no fluorosis had a mean DMFT of 3.0 which
was significantly higher than the mean of 2.2 among those with any
fluorosis. The proportion of subjects who rated the photographs as
poor or very poor fell from 29 per cent for TF score 0 to 15 per cent
for TF score 2 and then increased to 92 per cent for TF score 3. The
responses of the subjects regarding their desire for treatment matched
closely with their opinions on appearance; the majority of subjects
expressed concern over the appearance of teeth with TF scores of 3
and higher. It is concluded that the prevalence
of aesthetically objectionable dental fluorosis was low and that mild
fluorosis was associated with a lower risk of dental caries and a
more acceptable appearance. It is essential that a balanced view of
the relative benefits and risks of the use of fluorides is maintained
and proven benefits are not overwhelmed by largely unfounded aesthetic
concerns. |
|
17. Rahmatulla AH. Clinical evaluation
of two different techniques for the removal of fluorosis stains.
Egypt Dent J 1995 Jul;41(3):1287-94.
Department of Removable Prosthetic Dental Sciences, King Saud University,
College of Dentistry.
Dental fluorosis or mottled enamel manifest itself as a brown,
gray or black discolourations on the external enamel surfaces of
the permanent teeth. The causative factor has been found to be the
ingestion of fluorine in the drinking water more than 1 pp.m. In
its most severe form the enamel discolouration provide a very displeasing
appearance. Many times friends and relatives tease the patient that
these stains are associated with smoking and/or poor oral hygiene.
Such unwarranted, lose and inflicting
personal remarks leads an individual into a severe psychological
depression. A clinical study was under taken with its aims and objectives
to evaluate the efficaciousness of 18% hydrochloric acid with pumice
and McInnes solution with pumice in fighting the various forms of
fluorosis stains and also observe and record their actions and reactions
with the patients and the vitalities of the treated teeth.
|
|
18. Welbury RR, Shaw L.
A simple technique for removal of mottling, opacities and pigmentation
from enamel. Dent Update 1990 May;17(4):161-3.
Department of Child Dental Health, The Dental School, Newcastle
upon Tyne.
Mottling of teeth can have significant
psychological impact on patients--particularly on adolescents, who
may be subjected to much unkind teasing. A number of
procedures have been suggested for removal of mottling and stains.
The authors describe a simple and quick technique using a paste
of hydrochloric acid and pumice, and on the basis of their clinical
and laboratory experience suggest it as a treatment of first choice.
|
|
19. Riordan PJ. The
place of fluoride supplements in caries prevention today.
Aust Dent J 1996 Oct;41(5):335-42.
Health Department of Western Australia.
There are very few scientifically good clinical trials of fluoride
supplements, and those that can be considered methodologically adequate
suggest that the contribution of fluoride supplements to caries prevention
is slight. This may be partly a consequence of the fact that fluoride
is much more widely available today than was the case a generation
ago when fluoride toothpaste was not widely used and water fluoridation
was not fully implemented. Although some families are conscientious
in their use, compliance with fluoride supplement recommendations
is generally poor over longer periods, making them a poor public health
measure. There is substantial evidence that supplements cause dental
fluorosis when used in accordance with recommendations for infants
and small children. If the public becomes
concerned about dental fluorosis as an aesthetic problem, all fluoride
use may be put at risk. Supplements should no longer be
recommended for caries prevention in children in areas with little
fluoride in water but may be useful for persons with intractable caries
risks. If supplements are recommended for children, a more cautious
dosage schedule should be used. The fact that supplements have been
recommended uncritically for many years on the basis of inadequate
research raises questions about the standards of dental science. |
20. Clark DC,
Hann HJ, Williamson MF, Berkowitz J. Aesthetic
concerns of children and parents in relation to different classifications
of the Tooth Surface Index of Fluorosis. Community Dent Oral
Epidemiol. 1994 Dec;22(6):461-4.
Department of Clinical Dental Sciences, Faculty of Dentistry, University
of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
Increasing prevalence of dental fluorosis for children both from
fluoridated and non-fluoridated communities are now well documented.
Along with recent studies purporting possible adverse health effects
from fluorides, this proven public health intervention is again
being challenged. This study was undertaken to determine the prevalence
of dental fluorosis for children from fluoridated and non-fluoridated
areas in British Columbia. In addition, children and parents were
provided with an opportunity to express concerns about the aesthetics
of the child's anterior teeth. Children from representative schools
in two communities were surveyed using the Tooth Surface Index of
Fluorosis (TSIF). Questionnaires were sent home to parents to detail
their child's use of various fluoride preventive practices and residence
histories. Completed questionnaires were returned and exams were
performed on 1131 children. Of those examined, 60% had dental fluorosis
on at least two tooth surfaces, only 8% had scores ranging from
"2" to "6", and 52% were classified with a score
of "1". Parental and child ratings on the aesthetics or
color of the child's teeth suggests that there are few children
with aesthetic problems in the TSIF category of "1". While
concerns of parents were more common, the actual source of those
concerns was not assessed in the questionnaire. Not
unexpectedly, children with fluorosis on anterior teeth ranging
between TSIF scores of "2" to "6" appear to
have increased concerns about tooth color. Data from
children with confirmed residence histories from fluoridated communities
suggest that the occurrence of aesthetic problems in these children
is rare.
|
|
21. Griffin SO, Beltran ED, Lockwood SA, Barker LK. Esthetically
objectionable fluorosis attributable to water fluoridation.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2002 Jun;30(3):199-20.
Division of Oral Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
Atlanta, GA, USA. sig1@cdc.gov
OBJECTIVE: We compared estimates of fluorosis prevalence and risk
attributable to fluoridation using an index applied to the entire
dentition and to the maxillary anterior teeth. We also estimated
the prevalence of perceived esthetic problems attributable to current
fluoridation policy (Attributable Burden). METHODS: Fluorosis prevalence
estimates were obtained from the National Survey of Oral Health
in US School Children (1986-87) for the 1839 survey children aged
12 -14 years who were scored for fluorosis, had never received fluoride
drops or tablets, and had lived in only one home. For each child
we calculated Dean's fluorosis index, and an anterior fluorosis
index (value of the highest scored maxillary anterior tooth). We
used each index to calculate risk of fluorosis attributable to fluoridation
by subtracting at each level of severity the prevalence of fluorosis
among those living in low fluoride areas (F <or= 0.3 ppm) from
the prevalence among those living in optimally fluoridated areas
(0.7 ppm F <or=1.2 ppm). Findings from five published studies
were used to calculate risk of perceived esthetic problem attributable
to fluorosis, by severity, i.e. the difference in the mean percentage
of respondents who were satisfied with the appearance of their teeth
with and without fluorosis. Finally, Attributable Burden was estimated
by summing the products of risk of perceived esthetic problems attributable
to fluorosis and risk of fluorosis attributable to fluoridation
for each level of fluorosis severity. RESULTS: Prevalence of fluorosis,
very mild or greater, was 26% with Dean's Index, which was significantly
higher than the 18% figure calculated with the anterior index. Using
the anterior index, fluoridation was a risk factor for very mild
(attributable risk = 15%) and mild fluorosis (attributable risk
= 3%). Risk of fluorosis (very mild or greater) attributable to
fluoridation was significantly higher when calculated from prevalence
estimates using Dean's Index than estimates calculated with the
anterior index (24% versus 18%). The mean values of risk of perceived
esthetic problems attributable to very mild and mild fluorosis were
9% and 33%, respectively. CONCLUSION: We
found that approximately 2% of US schoolchildren may experience
perceived esthetic problems which could be attributed to the currently
recommended levels of fluoride in drinking water. The
findings further suggest that both estimates of fluorosis prevalence
and risk of fluorosis attributable to fluoridation will be higher
when calculated with an index applied to the entire dentition. Data
were unavailable for fluoridated toothpaste and diluted formula
consumption, thus the risk of fluorosis attributable to fluoridation
may be overestimated if consumption was higher in fluoridated areas.
The risk of perceived esthetic problems
attributable to fluoridation must be weighed against its lifetime
benefits and the associated costs of alternative solutions such
as educating parents about appropriate toothpaste use and lowering
the fluoride content of children's toothpaste.
|
|
22. McKnight CB, Levy SM, Cooper SE, Jakobsen JR. A
pilot study of esthetic perceptions of dental fluorosis vs. selected
other dental conditions. ASDC J Dent Child 1998 Jul-Aug;65(4):233-8,
229.
College of Dentistry, University of Iowa, Iowa City, USA.
The prevalence of fluorosis has increased over the past fifty years,
and with this increase, esthetic concerns pertaining to fluorosis
should also be taken into consideration. Canadian, Australian, and
British studies have explored perceptions concerning enamel fluorosis,
but no studies in this area have been published from the United
States. In the previous studies, esthetic concerns resulting from
fluorosis generally were not compared with the esthetic perceptions
of other conditions such as isolated opacities, tetracycline staining,
or various types of malocclusion. In the present investigation,
respondents answered written questions about paired photographs,
one of fluorotic teeth and the other with one of the other conditions.
Results show that not only is fluorosis
noticeable, but it may be more of an esthetic concern than the other
conditions.
|
|
23. Riordan PJ. Perceptions of dental
fluorosis. J Dent Res 1993 Sep;72(9):1268-74.
Dental Services, Health Department of Western Australia, Como.
Mild dental fluorosis has long been accepted as a side-effect of
water fluoridation and, more recently, has been recognized as a
consequence of the use of other fluoride-based caries-preventive
strategies. Traditionally, dental health professionals have not
seen this as being of public health importance, but members of the
public have not been asked their opinion. The purpose of the present
study was to gather the opinions of lay groups concerning the appearance
of the teeth of children with various degrees of fluorosis. Twenty-eight
children, born in 1978, who had earlier participated in a study
of fluorosis in Perth (Western Australia), allowed 110 observers
to look at their upper central incisors under good viewing conditions.
Fluorosis in these teeth ranged from TF score 0 (no fluorosis) to
TF score 3. The observers were university students, parents, public
servants, or dentists. They responded to statement items about the
appearance of the teeth. The results, based
on just over 3000 responses, showed that lay and dental observers
could distinguish between different fluorosis levels. In response
to a statement that the teeth appeared pleasing, a large majority
agreed when the TF score was 0, but agreement declined as the TF
score increased; when the TF score was 3, most people disagreed.
Similarly, observers felt that the appearance would increasingly
embarrass the child as the TF score increased. Observers, except
the dentists, tended to feel that higher TF scores indicated neglect
on the part of the child.
|
|
24. P.G. Colon, Removal of Tooth Stains
in Prisoner Rehabilitation, Dental Survey Publications, Vol:
48: No 22, 1972.
Federal Correctional Institution, Terminal Island, San Pedro
California (1972)
The stains of endemic Dental Fluorosis
can have a tremendous psychological impact on the patient. Perhaps
this might be a contributory factor in the psychological make-up
of the individual who displays anti-social behavior. If so, it might
be possible to effect change by removing the stains. Many patients
[convicts] have been pleased with the results [bleaching of teeth],
and even displayed a willingness to smile.
|
|
25. Nyaora Moturi WK, Tole MP, Davies TC - "The
Contribution of Drinking Water Towards Dental Fluorosis:
A Case Study of Nyoro Division, Nakuro District,
Kenya" Environmental Geochemistry and Health 24:123-130 (2002)
More than 80% of respondents felt that
dental fluorosis is a problem, because of (i) the unsightly nature
of teeth, (ii) it is difficult to chew with mottled teeth as they
are susceptible to breakage, (iii) induces shyness, especially of
teenage girls. However, 74% of the respondents knew neither the
cause of dental fluorosis, nor the remedies for the problem.
|
|
26. Mothusi, B. Psychological Effects
of Dental Fluorosis. Department of Health, North West Province,
South Africa.
The trauma experienced by young people
with dental fluorosis is depressingly apparent in a SOUTH AFRICAN
study conducted by the North West Province Department of Health:
"The psychological effect in terms of the unsightly, brown-stained
teeth, has induced the adolescents with fluorosed teeth to demand
that these teeth be extracted and replaced with dentures."
|
| 27. Clark DC, Hann HJ, Williamson MF,
Berkowitz J. Aesthetic concerns of children
and parents in relation to different classifications of the Tooth
Surface Index of Fluorosis. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1993
Dec;21(6):360-4
Completed questionnaires were returned
and exams were performed on 1131 children. Of those examined, 60%
had dental fluorosis on at least two tooth surfaces, only 8% had
scores ranging from "2" to "6", and 52% were
classified with a score of "1". Parental and child ratings
on the aesthetics or color of the child's teeth suggests that there
are few children with aesthetic problems in the TSIF category of
"1". While concerns of parents were more common, the actual
source of those concerns was not assessed in the questionnaire.
Not unexpectedly, children with fluorosis on anterior teeth ranging
between TSIF scores of "2" to "6" appear to
have increased concerns about tooth color.
|
|
28. Clark DC. Evaluation of aesthetics
for the different classifications of the Tooth Surface Index of
Fluorosis. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 1995 Apr;23(2):80-3.
Pairs of semantic differentiated adjectives
adapted from SASOC were used
to rate fifty 35 mm slides of anterior teeth. Sampling of children
from the different categories of the Tooth Surface Index of Fluorosis
(TSIF) on anterior permanent teeth was weighted to permit sufficient
numbers of slides for the different classifications of the TSIF.
Each slide was presented to a stratified random sample of pairs
of parents and children who were participants in the original study.
A convenience sample of dental professionals was also included.
Analysis compared different classifications of "affected"
slides (non-zero TSIF scores), with the mean aesthetic score computed
from all "non-affected" slides (TSIF = 0). Results from
children, parents, and professionals showed that there were highly
significant differences between ratings of low and high TSIF scores.
The only non-significant differences were between TSIF 4 and TSIF
5 & 6, which all three groups did not distinguish, as well as
TSIF 1 versus TSIF 2 & 3, which children could not distinguish.
|
|
29. Mrs. Nipaphan Osiriphan, Master of Public Health
Examining Committee Assist. Prof. Dr. Komkham Pattanaporn Chairman
Lect. Chalermpong Chittaisong Member
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Pacharawan Srisilapanan Member
Assoc. Prof. Anchalee Dusadeepan Member
Perception of Dental Fluorosis among
People Residing in Tambon Doi Tao Changwat Chiang Mai
The objectives of this study were to study the severity of dental
fluorosis status, people perception, oral impacts affecting daily
performance of dental fluorosis in people and compare level of dental
fluorosis status estimated by using Dean's index and the perception
of people residing in Tambon Doi Tao, Ampur Doi Tao, Changwat Chiang
Mai. One hundred and seventy four subjects comprised of lay persons,
students, health personnel and headmen of villages, were recruited
using multistage sampling technique. Data were collected by oral
examination using Dean's and TSIF index of dental fluorosis and
interviewing for subjects' perception by using interview form. OIDP
index was used to assess their oral impacts affecting daily performance
and the pictures of dental fluorosis were used to compare status
level estimation. Data were analyzed by using descriptive statistics,
binomial and Spearman's correlation coefficient techniques.
The results revealed that the severity of dental fluorosis of
the samples were in a range of questionable to severe levels. Subjects'
perception of their dental fluorosis status was in medium level.
Dental fluorosis status affected daily performance in 24.1% of the
samples, in two performances: contacting with people and smiling.
Smiling impact was statistical significantly related to the severity
of dental fluorosis examined by Dean's index (p < 0.05). There
was statistical significantly difference in status estimation between
Dean's index and subjects' judgement (p < 0.05). Severity of
dental fluorosis which subjects considered to be a problem and need
to be solved, were at moderate to severe level. Health personnel
and the headmen of villages accepted that dental fluorosis was a
prioritized problem in their community but they lacked of knowledge
in this issue.
This study indicated that preventing and solving dental fluorosis
in this area should begins with providing information of dental
fluorosis to the community, encouraging them to solve their problems
holistically and providing technical support from the government.
|
|
More photographs of Dental Fluorosis
http://www.medisearch.co.uk/scripts/dental_preventing.asp
http://www.positivehealth.com/permit/Articles/Dentistry/gibsn24.htm
http://www.saveourwater.org/begin.html
http://www.edoc.co.za/dentalnet/articles/fluorosis.html
|
|